{
  "schema": "kairos-jubal-case/v1",
  "case_id": "jubal-kairos-case-1-lawful-data-perimeter-v1",
  "title": "Jubal Case 1 — lawful-data perimeter",
  "as_of": "2026-08-28",
  "status": "JUBAL LOWER-EVIDENCE EXCEPTION",
  "audience": "Kairos War Room team tier",
  "authority_ceiling": "Counsel-grade internal preparation. This record is not legal clearance, provider approval, access authorization, or licensed adjudication.",
  "blind_integrity": {
    "talos_answer_frozen_before_reveal": true,
    "sha256": "ecf68aed1d10c8ffb39d0c1463adc27ba363a2c1322e445a1ef519105cfb8a1a",
    "citation_gate": "13/13",
    "ieva_reply_opened_after_freeze": true,
    "relay_fidelity": "unknown",
    "independent_opposing_review": "pending",
    "licensed_adjudication": "not engaged for Phase 1"
  },
  "comparison": {
    "explicit_control_propositions": 13,
    "overlap": 13,
    "direct_contradictions": 0,
    "material_difference": "Purpose scope",
    "interpretation": "High convergence on issue spotting and control shape. This does not prove that either position is legally correct or that its factual conditions are satisfied."
  },
  "purpose_scope": {
    "ieva_answered": "General organisational information summarisation",
    "talos_matrix": [
      "company and product revenue perimeter",
      "customer or cohort quality",
      "cost, margin and headcount",
      "acquisition, retention, reactivation, payment recovery and paid tests"
    ],
    "consequence": "Only the narrow organisational-summary purpose inherits the shared framing. Each broader purpose requires its own purpose card and evidence."
  },
  "use_now": [
    "Public legal, corporate and product information",
    "Schema metadata without row values, credentials or secrets",
    "Legal-entity-only operational facts that do not identify a natural person",
    "Genuinely anonymous aggregates after singling-out, linkage and inference testing",
    "Purpose-bound aggregate query outputs from approved read-only views"
  ],
  "hold": [
    "Directly identifiable customer, employee, contractor or node-operator rows",
    "Special-category or inferable data",
    "Person-linked compensation, performance or HR data",
    "Communications content, traffic, precise location and person-linked node telemetry",
    "Payment-instrument detail and unnecessary person-linked transaction history",
    "Credentials, tokens, private keys and security-sensitive configuration",
    "Free text and message corpora by default",
    "Consumer AI paths with unevidenced training, retention, region or contractual role",
    "Outputs that rank, score, recommend or decide about a natural person"
  ],
  "unlock": [
    "One concrete purpose card",
    "Entity, controller, processor and recipient map",
    "Source-owner-validated field classification",
    "Anonymous or thresholded aggregate answer first",
    "Governed query-only access",
    "Pseudonymous rows only where aggregates fail, with split key custody",
    "Evidenced provider contract, settings, region, subprocessors and no-secondary-use path",
    "End-to-end retention and deletion schedule",
    "DPIA, LIA, compatibility and notice work where triggered",
    "Explicit human-review and no-individual-effect boundary",
    "Field-by-field expansion with a control owner and rollback"
  ],
  "unresolved": [
    "Exact VDAI source for Ieva's cited minimisation proposition",
    "Verbatim-versus-paraphrase fidelity of the relayed reply",
    "Actual MN entity and controller assignments",
    "Original-purpose, lawful-basis, notice and compatibility records",
    "Actual provider account, contract, region, subprocessor, training and retention settings",
    "Independent opposing review",
    "Licensed adjudication"
  ],
  "sources": [
    "10-projects/Kairos — Jubal Case 1 Dossier (2026-08-28).md",
    "10-projects/Kairos — Jubal Case 1 Blind Comparison (2026-08-28).md",
    "30-resources/legal/2026-08-28 — Ieva Case 1 blind framing reply.md"
  ],
  "raw_reply_deployed": false
}